In which we argue over Andy's moral fiber, discuss Dante's categorizations of evil, and consider the name-veto prerogative of any doctor who brings baby "Ansem Weems" into the world.
In which we discuss our zombie apocalypse teams, power dynamics between younger and older siblings, and Bethany’s least favorite Winchester shirt. Also featured: your feedback on the highs and lows of season 1!
In which we discuss the continuity of Dean's violent nature, Bethany's vampire racism, and the impossible command to "taint not thy mind" when hunting evil. (Also introduced: new segment "Sam Carries Women," and the unofficial Plaidcast drinking game.)
In which we discuss the "full desertness" of Dean's grief and the tragic loss of Sam's bangs, while painstakingly avoiding all discussion of clowns.
New season, new title card, new intro! This week we explore Supernatural's favorite topics (Death and Dad), and Michelle admits that Kripke can indeed write an amazing episode.
In which Michelle talks Bethany into a double episode and Bethany talks Michelle into actually RANKING the highs and lows of season 1.
In which we don't even bother discussing vampires...because they're probably extinct, right?
In which we discuss approaches to grief recovery, the symbolism of short sleeves, and the functions of fanfiction.
In which we discuss Macbeth parallels, the function of subjective flashbacks, and Sam's elusive purple whippet shirt.
In which we discuss parody vs. farce, the Winchesters as Jane Austen characters, and the futility of language in response to shirtless Sam.
In which we discuss Sam calling the shots and saving the day, the parallels of mortality and philosophy between Supernatural and Our Town, and John Winchester's enormous emotions.
In which we discuss alcohol tolerance, how to prioritize like Dean, and Sam saving the day. (Again.) (For the 5th time.) (Come on, Michelle, you can't deny it...)
In which we discuss bean bag chairs, devil's trap dog leashes, and what constitutes a believable lack of sleepwear - before eventually getting to the episode. (As usual, MAJOR SPOILERS for seasons 1-11).
In which we discuss candid brother moments, Dean Winchester's sex life, and the mysterious allure of neckties.
Special guest Rachel joins us to discuss Sam's coziest sweater, the history of tent revivals, and why John is still the Worst Dad Ever.
In which we discuss Meg 1.0, acceptable sacrifices, and the merits of trust vs. obedience.
In which we discuss horrible date ideas, gratuitous ghost shots, and the advanced technology of toasters.
In which we discuss Joseph Campbell's monomyth as it relates to Supernatural, the dangers of sink disposal systems, and John Winchester's eyelashes.
Bugs is notorious for being the “worst” episode of Supernatural…but we thought of a few episodes that make it look decent in comparison! Also featured: Michelle’s hatred of episode rankings, Dean’s love of steam showers, and “phat” as a compliment.
In which we discuss Sam's coffee preferences, the moral degradation of halter tops, and short sleeves for everyone!
In which we discuss hidden resentments, the sewers of the mind, and Sam as frisbee-playing Latin-tutoring Facebook lurker.
Bethany's phobias, guilt and mirror symbolism.
The details and mechanics of possession and exorcism and the comedy of Dean Winchester.
We discuss gorgeous lighting, Dean with kids and avoiding bathtubs.
Nightmares, Americana monsters, and Dean cheapening the moment.